Faced with controversy, park board once again fails to govern


The Minneapolis Parks and Recreation Board is in a difficult position when it comes to Lake Hiawatha and the Hiawatha Golf Course. It has been eight years since the 2014 flood that inundated the golf course and revealed unpermitted groundwater pumping, yet the park board still has not passed a plan to deal with the issue. A two-year-long public engagement effort guided the creation of a master plan to reduce the golf course to nine holes and add wetlands, water treatment, and additional recreational opportunities, but the park board keeps failing to move it forward.
The sticking point is Hiawatha’s historical role in the integration of city golf courses and the importance it continues to hold among Black golfers in Minneapolis. A group of golfers campaigning under the banner of Save Hiawatha 18 have made it clear that they consider anything less than 18 holes to be an attack on this heritage. Unhappily for the board, they face the reality that keeping 18 holes of golf at Hiawatha isn’t compatible with resolving the major water issues plaguing the site. Dealing with flooding and pollution requires space, and there isn’t enough space to build a flood-resilient 18-hole golf course, as well as the needed water management facilities.
An alternative proposal by Save Hiawatha 18 illustrates the cost of keeping 18 holes at this location. Their proposal would disconnect Minnehaha Creek from Lake Hiawatha, leaving the lake stagnant and unsuitable for recreation. It would also route a drainage channel along most of the non-golf-course shoreline, and would require lowering the level of both Lake Hiawatha and Lake Nokomis by three feet. Even if the park board acted against the wishes of surrounding neighborhoods to pursue an idea like this, it would be subject to approval and permitting by regulatory agencies such as the DNR and MPCA. These agencies would likely reject any plan like this that pushes our water problems into other jurisdictions, at which point the park board would find themselves back to square one, having wasted staff time and taxpayer money with nothing to show for it.
This sort of difficult decision is the reason we have elected leaders. It’s their job to sort through the complicated technical details, to listen to affected communities, subject matter experts, and their own staff, and to synthesize that information into a decision that best serves their constituents. It’s also their job to understand that you can’t always make everyone happy and that they will sometimes face harsh criticism, even for making the right decision.
Unfortunately, some commissioners seem to be following the example of the previously-seated board, who twice failed to advance resolutions about Hiawatha, instead passing the buck to the current board. Most recently, commissioners deadlocked on a procedural vote to schedule a public hearing on the Hiawatha Master Plan, leaving us once again with no forward progress of any sort.
More delay will not change the facts of this problem or cause a magical solution to arise where there wasn’t one before. Meanwhile, continued inaction is causing tangible harms:
• As anger rises on both sides over the constant revisiting of this issue, the rhetoric surrounding it is becoming more bitter and divisive.
• More than 1,000 pounds of trash per year enters the lake from the stormwater pipe. Some of this trash remains in the lake and harms the ecosystem there, while some of it travels downstream into Minnehaha Falls and the Mississippi River.
• An unquantified amount of phosphorous pollution enters the lake from a combination of upstream agriculture, golf course runoff, and groundwater pumping. This contributes to the lake’s murkiness and causes toxic algae blooms that keep the beach closed much of the summer.
• We continue to roll the dice on when the next flooding event will damage the existing golf course. The concern is a “10-year” flood event, which happens on average once every 10 years. Nobody can predict when the next one is, but we are now eight years past the last event, so the odds are only getting worse. FEMA assistance was required to recover from the 2014 flood, and they have made it clear that they won’t be stepping in a second time.
We don’t elect leaders for them to hide behind nice words and hope that problems go away on their own. During debate on the recent resolution, Commissioner Shaffer stated that “this could be our story." Indeed it might. This may be the defining moment in which our newly seated park board decides if they will run away from every difficult decision, or if they will acknowledge their responsibility to lead, even when it’s hard.
Ian Young is with Hiawatha 4 All. Find more at


1 comment on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here

  • JMoore

    Ridiculous take. Now you are blaming the board for not closing the Hiawatha Golf Course. Forgot the black history of the course, Stephanie Musich has, Meg Forney has. Easy to reduce Hiawatha GC's black history to a plaque. Once in 10 year event? You forgot a zero, once in 100 year event! Next time it happens you nor I will be here. Sorry those in the Save Hiawatha 18 camp are not following your slave mater mentality, and we are not falling in line. There is like 10 parks with in a mile or so from the course. You are saying none of those parks can handle the new recreation you speak of? I grew up at McCrae Park, under used, and I never see it being used, yet we are not talking about closing it down. Once a lively park full of kids, now sits empty most of the time. The golf course houses all the youth high school golf teams on the South side, runs youth programs like First Tee that serves the underprivileged youth black, white and all. My kids started their golf lessons at Hiawatha. People come from all over to play, practice and meet at the course. It is a gathering place, is it too many black people in one place? These micro aggressions are what black people have been dealing with from white people for centuries. Anything that is deemed ours has to be shut down or reduced to a size white people can deal with. The failure of the park board is not putting the money in all the course, not just Hiawatha GC. I will not understand why the park board has yet to build a club house at Meadowbrook as mandated by the city of Hopkins 5 plus years ago. Minneapolis Country Club has offered to purchase Meadowbrook GC many times, and the park board/city turned them down. Reducing Hiawatha golf course will take millions, why not use those millions too improve ALL the golf courses to allow them to turn more of a profit. Instead they continue the fight to close the only South Mpls golf course in the city of Minneapolis. Meadowbrook is in Hopkins, Tho Wirth is in Golden Valley, Francis A. Gross is in St. Anthony, Fort Snelling is that Minneapolis? Only Columbia (NE Mpls) and Hiawatha GC's are in Minneapolis proper, every other course is somewhere else. No one talks about that, because that is where the white people are. Black Lives Matter sign looks good on a sign in your front yard, while you are in the backyard white washing black history. A plaque, give me a break. That is what black history means to your group.

    Sunday, May 22, 2022 Report this